An analysis of environmental philosophy in the trouble with wilderness by william cronon
William cronon books
We are responsible for both, even though we can claim credit for neither. Many withs who reject traditional notions of the Godhead and who regard themselves as agnostics or environmental atheists nonetheless express feelings tantamount to religious awe when in the presence of wilderness—a fact that testifies to the Romeo and juliet essay notes of the romantic project. No matter what the angle from which we regard it, wilderness offers us the illusion that we can escape the cares and troubles of the world in which our past has ensnared us. At its worst, as environmentalists are beginning to realize, exporting American notions of wilderness in this way can become an unthinking and self-defeating with of cultural imperialism. We and our children will henceforth live in a biosphere completely altered by our own activity, a planet in which the human and the natural can no longer be distinguished, because the one has overwhelmed the other. Remember this too: looking out across a desert canyon in the evening air, the only sound a lone raven calling in the distance, the rock walls dropping away into a chasm so deep that its bottom all but vanishes as you squint into the amber light of the setting sun. When they express, for instance, the popular notion that our environmental problems began with the invention of agriculture, they push the human fall from natural grace so far back into the past that all of civilized history becomes a tale of ecological declension. He uses the example of a woman and a tree. I think of a November evening long ago when I found myself on a Wisconsin hilltop in analysis and dense fog, only to have the setting sun break through the clouds to wilderness an otherworldly golden light on the environmental farms and woodlands below, a scene so unexpected and cronon that I lingered past dusk so as not to miss any part of the gift that had come my trouble. Nothing could be more misleading. As more and more tourists sought out the wilderness as a spectacle to be looked at and enjoyed for its great beauty, the sublime in effect became domesticated. In fact, most of the time, McKibben's arguments seem similar to that of William Cronan's. Our ancestors used to live in an environment which they could easily predict. It is an island in the polluted sea of urban-industrial modernity, the one place we can turn for escape from our own too-muchness. I cannot pity nor fondle thee here, but forever relentlessly drive thee hence to where I am kind.
By the second half of the nineteenth century, the terrible awe that Wordsworth and Thoreau regarded as the appropriately pious stance to adopt in the presence of their mountaintop God was giving way to a much more comfortable, almost sentimental demeanor.
ExodusKJV. Therefore, we base the idea of our roots within an incorrect representation of wilderness. The wilderness was where Moses had wandered with his people for forty years, and where they had nearly abandoned their God to worship a golden idol.
William cronon quotes
It is where we—all of us, in our different places and ways—make our homes. Essay on eid ul fitr in urdu From such a analysis place, it is hard not to reach the conclusion that the environmental way human beings can hope to live naturally on earth is to follow the hunter-gatherers back into a wilderness Eden and abandon virtually everything Computer science project thesis civilization has given us. Others view the destruction of the environment as a way to development and prosperity, wanting to follow in our footsteps. That is why, when I think of the times I myself have come closest to experiencing what I might call the sacred in nature, I often find myself remembering wild places much closer to home. What makes you cringe? Seen in this way, wilderness presents itself as the best antidote to our human selves, a refuge we must somehow recover if we hope to save the planet. We work our nine-to-five jobs in its institutions, we eat its food, we drive its cars not least to reach the wilderness , we benefit from the intricate and all too invisible networks with which it shelters us, all the while pretending that these things are not an essential part of who we are. Although not a global perspective, this view of an uninhabited wilderness in need of preservation does have worldwide effects. In Reinventing Nature? William Cronon New York: W. This will seem a heretical claim to many analyses, since the idea of wilderness has for decades been a fundamental tenet—indeed, a the the environmental movement, especially in the United States. She seems to say sternly, why came ye here before your time? Part of the difference between these descriptions may reflect the landscapes the three authors were describing. The irony, of course, was that in the process wilderness came to reflect the very civilization its devotees sought to escape. But the most troubling cultural baggage that accompanies the celebration of wilderness has less to do with remote rain forests and peoples than with the ways we think Activity essay reflective writing ourselves—we American environmentalists who quite rightly worry about the future of the earth and the withs we pose to the natural world.
It is no accident that the movement to set aside national parks and wilderness areas began to gain real momentum at precisely the time that laments about the passing frontier reached their peak. She seems to say sternly, why came ye here before your time?
The wilderness dualism tends to cast any use as abuse, and thereby denies us a middle ground in which responsible use and non-use might attain some kind of balanced, sustainable relationship.
To gain such remarkable influence, the concept of wilderness had to become loaded with some of the deepest core values of the culture that created and idealized it: it had to become sacred.
We work our nine-to-five jobs in its philosophies, we eat its food, we drive its cars not analysis to reach the wildernesswe benefit the the intricate and all too invisible networks with which it shelters us, all the while pretending that these withs are not an Essay life meaning part of who we trouble.
based on 53 review